Investment Outlook
Positive outlook with 8.5% upside potential driven by strategic transformation
POSITIVE Outlook
QBE Insurance Group presents a compelling investment opportunity with an 8.5% upside to our base case valuation of A$19.10, supported by strong fundamentals and strategic transformation progress. The company's 18.2% adjusted ROE in 2024 demonstrates significant improvement from historical levels, driving our positive outlook despite ongoing execution challenges in select segments.
The valuation primarily reflects QBE's strategic portfolio reshaping and de-risking initiatives, particularly the meaningful progress in transforming the North America division through middle-market exit and the $1.6 billion reserve transaction. These actions have substantially reduced earnings volatility and positioned the company for more consistent performance. The International division's excellent underwriting results (88.7% combined ratio) and Australia Pacific's improving profitability further support our positive assessment.
While we acknowledge ongoing challenges including Crop performance and persistent inflation in certain segments, these are more than offset by QBE's enhanced catastrophe management, favorable pricing environment, and strong investment returns. Our valuation range is supported by QBE's robust capital position (1.86x PCA multiple), disciplined approach to portfolio optimization, and potential for consistent dividend growth.
Executive Summary
Strong performance transformation with strategic portfolio optimization driving improved returns
QBE Insurance Group has delivered exceptional financial improvement in 2024, with adjusted net profit increasing 27% to $1,729 million and the combined operating ratio improving to 93.1% from 95.2%. This transformation has been driven by deliberate portfolio optimization initiatives, including the exit from underperforming segments like North America middle-market and a $1.6 billion reserve transaction that de-risked approximately 10% of total net reserves.
The company's strategic pivot from "historic challenges" to "opportunities ahead" is evident in the strong divisional performance. International delivered an exceptional 88.7% combined ratio with 11% growth, contributing 72% of the Group's operating result. North America showed significant improvement with a 4.8 percentage point combined ratio improvement to 98.9%, despite ongoing challenges in Crop insurance. Australia Pacific improved to a 92.0% combined ratio while advancing key modernization initiatives.
Investment performance provided substantial support with a 4.9% total return, benefiting from higher interest rates and strategic portfolio positioning. QBE extended fixed income duration from 1.7 to 2.4 years and increased risk asset allocation to 14%, positioning for continued strong returns. The 40% dividend increase to 87 Australian cents per share with a 50% payout ratio signals management confidence in sustainable earnings improvement. With non-core run-off expected to halve in 2025 and continued benefits from portfolio optimization, QBE is well-positioned for consistent performance improvement.
Company Overview
Global P&C insurer with leading franchises across commercial and specialty markets
QBE Insurance Group Limited is an international insurer and reinsurer headquartered in Sydney and listed on the Australian Securities Exchange. Operating across 26 countries with approximately 13,275 employees, QBE holds leading franchises across commercial and specialty markets organized into three operational divisions: North America, International, and Australia Pacific. The company's stated purpose is "Enabling a more resilient future."
QBE maintains particular strength in specialty markets and has established significant market positions in commercial P&C segments across its operating regions. In 2024, the company reported gross written premium of $22.4 billion, demonstrating its substantial scale in the global insurance market. Their business mix was: International (44% of GWP), North America (32%), and Australia Pacific (24%).
Key Market Positions
QBE holds particularly strong market positions in SME through middle-market commercial P&C segments in Australia and the UK, specialty classes through its Lloyd's franchise, crop insurance in North America, and lenders mortgage insurance in Australia. Key sectors include agriculture, public/product liability, motor, marine/energy/aviation, and professional indemnity.
The company generates revenue primarily through insurance premiums across diverse product lines including commercial property and casualty, specialty lines, reinsurance, crop insurance, and lenders mortgage insurance. Their underwriting activities are complemented by investment income derived from their substantial investment portfolio ($30.6 billion in 2024). QBE employs both direct distribution and broker channels, with recent strategic focus on deepening distribution relationships around growth areas.
Latest Results
Strong FY2024 performance with significant improvements across key metrics
Metric | 2024 | 2023 | Change |
---|---|---|---|
Gross written premium (US$M) | 22,395 | 21,748 | +3% |
Combined operating ratio (%) | 93.1 | 95.2 | -2.1pts |
Insurance profit (US$M) | 2,130 | 1,617 | +32% |
Net profit after tax (US$M) | 1,779 | 1,355 | +31% |
Adjusted ROE (%) | 18.2 | 15.8 | +2.4pts |
Investment return (%) | 4.9 | 4.7 | +0.2pts |
QBE delivered outstanding financial performance in 2024, with significant improvements across all key metrics. Gross written premium grew 3% to $22.4 billion despite strategic exits from underperforming portfolios, while net insurance revenue increased more substantially by 7% to $17.8 billion. The combined operating ratio improved significantly to 93.1% from 95.2%, driven by lower catastrophe costs and more stable reserve development.
Profitability metrics showed substantial growth, with insurance profit increasing 32% to $2.1 billion and net profit after tax rising 31% to $1.8 billion. This translated to a 2.4 percentage point improvement in adjusted return on equity to 18.2%. Investment performance was solid with a 4.9% return, supported by higher interest rates and strong risk asset performance.
Divisional Performance Highlights
- North America: Combined ratio improved 4.8pts to 98.9% following middle-market exit and reserve transaction
- International: Exceptional 88.7% combined ratio with 11% growth, contributing 72% of operating results
- Australia Pacific: Improved to 92.0% combined ratio while advancing modernization initiatives
The strength of these results enabled QBE to increase its dividend by 40% to 87 Australian cents per share, representing a 50% payout ratio. Balance sheet metrics also improved, with debt to total capital decreasing to 19.9% and the PCA multiple strengthening to 1.86x. The $1.6 billion reserve transaction significantly de-risked the portfolio, removing a major source of potential volatility and providing greater earnings certainty going forward.
Financial Forecasts
Progressive improvement expected with combined ratio reaching 91.5% by 2029
Our financial forecast projects continued improvement in QBE's performance, with gross written premium growth accelerating from 3.0% in 2025 to 4.5% by 2029. This reflects both moderating premium rate increases (from 5.5% to 3.5%) and improving volume growth as portfolio exits cease impacting results. The combined operating ratio is forecast to improve gradually from 93.1% in 2024 to 91.5% by 2029, driven by portfolio optimization benefits and reduced volatility.
Net profit after tax is projected to grow from $1.8 billion in 2024 to $1.9 billion by 2029, with growth moderating in later years as investment returns normalize from current elevated levels. Investment income is expected to decline slightly from $1.5 billion to $1.4 billion as yields moderate from 4.9% to 4.2%, though this remains above historical averages due to strategic asset allocation changes.
Base Case
- Combined ratio: 91.5%
- Investment return: 4.2%
- ROE: 16.5%
Bull Case
- Combined ratio: 89.5%
- Investment return: 4.8%
- ROE: 19.0%
Bear Case
- Combined ratio: 94.0%
- Investment return: 3.5%
- ROE: 13.0%
Key assumptions include North America's non-core run-off halving in 2025 and becoming minimal by 2026, continued favorable prior year development, and catastrophe claims remaining stable at approximately 6.0% of net insurance revenue. The dividend payout ratio is assumed to increase gradually from 50% to 55%, supporting steady dividend growth while maintaining capital strength.
Valuation Analysis
Multiple methodologies support A$19.10 base case with 8.5% upside potential
Methodology | Implied Price Per Share |
---|---|
DCF - Base Case | A$19.10 |
DCF - Bull Case | A$23.20 |
DCF - Bear Case | A$14.80 |
P/E Multiple - NTM | A$19.15 |
P/B Multiple | A$19.10 |
ROE vs. Cost of Equity | A$22.05 |
Precedent Transactions | A$16.00 |
Implied Valuation Range | A$18.50 - A$21.50 |
Our valuation approach combines traditional DCF methodology with insurance-specific metrics including P/B multiples and ROE/COE analysis, reflecting QBE's unique business characteristics as a global P&C insurer. The base case DCF-derived value of A$19.10 represents our primary valuation, incorporating a 9.1% WACC and 3.0% terminal growth rate applied to forecasted cash flows through 2029.
The valuation is closely aligned with our P/E multiple approach (A$19.15), which applies a 12.5x multiple to 2025E earnings, reflecting QBE's improved profitability profile and reduced risk. The P/B multiple approach yields a similar A$19.10 valuation, using a 1.8x multiple on 2024 book value per share, appropriate for a P&C insurer with an 18.2% ROE.
Key Valuation Drivers
- North America transformation reducing earnings volatility
- International division's consistent outperformance
- Strategic portfolio de-risking through $1.6B reserve transaction
- Enhanced investment returns from higher interest rates
- Improved capital efficiency and dividend sustainability
The ROE vs. Cost of Equity approach yields our highest valuation at A$22.05, highlighting QBE's potential for multiple expansion if it sustains its improved returns over time. Based on our analysis and weighting different methodologies, we derive an implied valuation range of A$18.50-A$21.50, representing potential upside of 5-22% from the current A$17.60 share price. The variance between methodologies primarily reflects differing perspectives on the sustainability of QBE's improved ROE and the pace of the North America transformation.
Risk Analysis
Key risks include catastrophe exposure, transformation execution, and inflation pressures
Catastrophe Exposure
Impact: Could significantly affect annual results despite improved resilience
Despite portfolio exits reducing exposure by ~50%, natural catastrophe risk remains inherent to P&C operations. Climate change may increase frequency and severity over time.
North America Transformation
Impact: Critical to achieving consistent performance goals
Non-core run-off still contributed ~$220M loss in 2024. Successful execution of portfolio reshaping is crucial to valuation as NA represents 32% of group premium.
Inflation & Reserving Risk
Impact: Affects claims costs and reserve adequacy
Claims inflation remains "nuanced by class and region" at ~5%. Social inflation in liability lines poses additional reserve risk, especially for long-tail classes.
Investment Market Risk
Impact: Direct impact on earnings given significant contribution
Expected moderation in yields from current 4.9% could affect earnings. Interest rate changes impact both investment returns and reserve valuations.
QBE has demonstrated improved resilience through strategic portfolio optimization, with catastrophe costs $232 million below allowance in 2024. The $1.6 billion reserve transaction significantly de-risked older accident years, while management expects North America's non-core run-off to "broadly halve in FY25." However, execution risks remain in managing the orderly transformation while maintaining underwriting discipline in a competitive market environment.
The company's enhanced geographical diversification and improved portfolio balance provide downside protection, while successful completion of strategic initiatives offers significant upside potential. Management's transparent risk disclosures and methodical approach to mitigation support confidence in their ability to address key exposures while capitalizing on growth opportunities.